Five Tactics to Make Decisions in Meetings
1) Start with a written decision question
Write the single question the meeting must answer and share it ahead of time. State the success criteria in simple words that a new hire could understand. Invite only people who own inputs or will execute the result.
Try this: Put the question at the top of the agenda: “Should we do X now, later, or not at all, and why.” Add the three success criteria under it.
Why it works: A clear question sets the target for every comment. Success criteria prevent drift into status or opinion.
2) Use a one-page memo and begin with silent reading
Talking before reading creates uneven context and loud voices win. A short memo levels knowledge and puts evidence on the table. Quiet reading protects attention and speeds useful debate.
Try this: Share a one-page memo with Problem, Context, Options, Recommendation, and Risks. Open the meeting with six minutes of silent reading, then collect written questions.
Why it works: Writing compresses fuzzy thinking and exposes gaps. Shared facts raise the quality of discussion fast.
3) Declare the decision rule and the DRI up front
Groups stall when they do not know how a call will be made. Decide whether this will be a DRI call after input, a consent check, or an escalation. Put a name beside owner and a time beside decision.
Try this: Say, “Alex is the DRI. Inputs close today at 5 pm. The call will be made then.” Confirm what evidence matters most.
Why it works: Process clarity lowers resistance. A visible clock and owner convert talk into action.
4) Run tight rounds, then converge to a choice
Unstructured debate rewards volume and status. Timed rounds give each voice space and keep the room balanced. Convergence turns points into a decision with reasons.
Try this: Give each attendee one minute for their view, then list two to three viable options on the board. Vote for preference and risk, then let the DRI decide and state the reasons.
Why it works: Rounds surface quiet expertise and reduce grandstanding. Convergence converts ideas into a single path.
5) Record the decision and the first two steps
Decisions fade when they are not written. A short note preserves context, owners, and dates. Sharing the note ends debate and starts work.
Try this: Capture choice, two reasons, two risks, owner, next two steps, and a review date in one page. Send it within 24 hours to attendees and stakeholders.
Why it works: Written clarity prevents re-litigation. Visible next steps create immediate momentum.