3 DAYS AGO • 4 MIN READ

The Rule Nobody Remembers

profile

Learn Leadership

We are Learn Leadership. We turn real leaders’ stories into practical lessons you can use at work. New editions every Sunday and Thursday.

The Rule Nobody Remembers

Hello Learners,

This is Learn Leadership. Every issue takes one thing that quietly goes wrong between managers and their teams, shows it happening through a real story, and leaves you with something to try this week.

Today it's the rule nobody remembers making, the one your team still follows because that's how it's done. You'll leave with three questions that tell you whether a process still earns its place or just survives out of habit.

The keyboard you're typing on

Look down at your keyboard. The top row of letters starts QWERTY, and it makes almost no sense. The most common letters in English sit under your weakest fingers. The layout slows you down.

It was built that way on purpose, about 150 years ago, for a machine that no longer exists.

In the 1870s, a Milwaukee newspaper editor named Christopher Sholes was tinkering with one of the first typewriters. It had a flaw. When someone hit two neighboring keys in quick succession, the metal-type bars collided and jammed. The common story is that Sholes scattered the frequent letter pairs across the keyboard so the bars that fired together sat farther apart, and the jamming eased.

The jamming was solved soon after, with better mechanics. Typewriters themselves are gone. The glass screens we type on now have no bars to collide. And yet here you are, a century and a half later, still reaching for letters in an order built to protect a machine most people have never even seen.

Even Sholes had doubts. Near the end of his life he patented a different, saner layout. It went nowhere.

What QWERTY actually is now

QWERTY is a zombie rule. The reason it existed died, and the rule kept walking.

Once the biggest typewriter makers merged in the 1890s and agreed to standardize on it, QWERTY stopped being a choice. A generation of typists learned it. They trained the next generation. Every machine shipped with it, so every new machine had to match it, so every typist had to learn it, which meant every machine had to keep it.

​A better layout arrived in 1936, designed by August Dvorak, with the common letters resting right under your fingers. It's measurably faster. Almost nobody uses it.

The rule won for one reason. It was already everywhere, and everywhere is hard to argue with. A zombie rule never has to be the best option. It only has to be the current one: the thing everybody already knows, the change nobody wants to be responsible for.

Why the reason disappears but the rule doesn't

The pattern is simple, and it runs the same whether it's a keyboard or your team.

Someone makes a rule to solve a real problem sitting in front of them today. The rule works. Time passes. The problem fades, or the tool changes, or the person who understood the reason moves on. The rule stays, because undoing it takes someone noticing it, questioning it, and putting their name on the risk of removing it.

Nobody does. So the rule quietly becomes "how we do things," and "how we do things" is almost impossible to see, because it's the water everyone is swimming in.

The five-step approval on your team

You have zombie rules too. They're just less famous than a keyboard.

Consider a five-step sign-off that every small piece of work has to crawl through. Trace it back, and you'll usually find a single incident years ago. One email went out with the wrong price. One contract slipped through with a bad clause. Someone added a review step, which was the right call that day. Then another incident added another step. Each one made sense on its own.

Then the people who remembered the incidents left. The tools changed. The risk faded. The five steps stayed, and now a two-line update takes nine days, and not one person in the chain can tell you why it's five steps and not two.

That's QWERTY. The machine is long gone. The layout is still here.

Three questions for one rule

You won't fix every zombie rule this week, and you shouldn't try. Pick one. The one a new hire always trips on is a good bet, because new people can still see the water. Then ask three questions, in order:

  1. What problem was this built to solve? If nobody can answer, that alone should worry you. A rule whose reason has gone missing is running on pure momentum, exactly like the keyboard.
  2. Would that problem actually happen today without the rule? Sometimes the risk is still real. Often it left with the person who caused it, or the system that made it possible got replaced two years ago.
  3. What is the rule costing right now? Count it honestly: days of delay, people pulled into threads, and good work sitting in a queue waiting for a signature that changes nothing.

If the reason's gone and the cost is real, trim a step or kill the rule and watch what breaks. Usually nothing does. This part is uncomfortable, because removing a rule means putting your name on the risk it was covering. Do it anyway.

Find your QWERTY

Every team is typing on a 150-year-old keyboard somewhere.

A form field nobody reads. A standing meeting that solved something back in 2021. A report you build every Friday that you've never seen anyone open. The weekly approval from a person who left last spring.

Pick the one that came to mind just now, and ask it the three questions this week. You'll either find it still earns its place, which is worth knowing, or you'll hand your team back hours they didn't realize they were losing to a machine that stopped existing a long time ago.

Feedback

​Subscribe to participate in polls.

If you have specific feedback or anything interesting you’d like to share, please let us know by replying to this email.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Learn Leadership

We are Learn Leadership. We turn real leaders’ stories into practical lessons you can use at work. New editions every Sunday and Thursday.