7 DAYS AGO • 3 MIN READ

Why "Maybe" Is The Worst Answer

profile

Learn Leadership

We are Learn Leadership. We turn real leaders’ stories into practical lessons you can use at work. New editions every Sunday and Thursday.

Why "Maybe" Is The Worst Answer

Hello Learners,

This is Learn Leadership. Every issue takes one thing that quietly goes wrong between managers and their teams, shows it happening through a real story, and leaves you with something to try this week.

Today it's the raise you said you'd check on and the weeks of quiet that followed. You'll leave with a two-sentence message that ends the silence, even when you still don't have the answer.

The experiment with the snakes and the shocks

In 2016, a team of neuroscientists at University College London ran a small, slightly cruel experiment. Forty-five people played a computer game. They turned over rocks, and under some of the rocks was a snake. A snake meant a mild electric shock to the hand.

The odds kept changing. Sometimes a rock was almost certainly safe. Sometimes it almost certainly hid a snake. And sometimes it was a coin flip.

The researchers measured stress every way they could: what people reported, how much they sweated, how wide their pupils opened, and even their cortisol. Then they lined the stress up against the odds.

The result was the surprising part. People were not most stressed when a shock was certain. They were most stressed at fifty-fifty, when they had no idea what was coming. A guaranteed shock was easier to sit with than a maybe.

The lead researcher, Archy de Berker, summed it up simply: the worst state to be in is not knowing.

Silence is the fifty-fifty

Now put that in your office.

When someone on your team asks for something that matters, a raise, a promotion, a yes or no on their idea, and you say "let me check and get back to you," you think you've given a neutral, honest holding answer. You have. For about a week.

After that, your silence becomes the fifty-fifty rock. They don't know whether the answer is yes or no. Maybe you forgot. Maybe you're dodging. All three live in their head at once, and according to a lab full of electric shocks, that not-knowing is physically harder to carry than a clean no would be.

You meant to be careful. What you actually did was hand them weeks of the single most stressful state a person can be in.

Why "let me check" turns into a verdict

Uncertainty doesn't stay empty. People fill it, and they rarely fill it with the kind version.

Money and status make it worse, because those feel like a direct measure of how much someone is valued. So week by week, the silence writes its own story. Week one, they give you the benefit of the doubt. A few weeks later, the story turns: maybe it's a quiet no. A few weeks after that, they've decided they aren't worth the awkward conversation, and they've started looking.

Your calendar was the real reason you went quiet. They can't see your calendar. They see the silence, and silence always picks the harsher meaning.

Give them a date, not an answer

The fix comes straight out of the experiment. The pain lived in the not-knowing, so you don't need the answer to help them. You need to end the uncertainty.

End it with a date. Go to them and say two things: where it honestly stands, and when they'll get a real answer. "I haven't forgotten your raise. I'm still working it through the budget, and I'll have a firm yes or no for you by the 20th." That's the whole message. Even a likely no, with a date attached, moves them off the fifty-fifty rock and lets them breathe.

A date is a promise you can keep even when the answer is out of your hands. And keeping it is how the trust you've been quietly spending comes back.

When the date slips

Sometimes the date arrives and you still don't have the answer. The temptation is to go quiet again until you do. Don't. A second silence confirms the story they'd started telling themselves, and it costs more than the first.

If you're going to miss the date, reach them before it passes with a new one. "I said the 20th and I don't have it yet. My boss is back Thursday, so I'll have it by the 25th." It's a small, slightly awkward message. It also keeps you in the group of people who do what they say.

One thing to avoid. Don't replace the silence with a vague "soon." To the person waiting, "soon" is just a quieter way of saying never. A real date, every time.

The person you left hanging

You have someone on the fifty-fifty rock right now. They asked you for something that mattered, you said "let me check," and the weeks piled up while you were busy.

Their name just surfaced in your head.

Send them two sentences today: where it stands, and when they'll know. You might not love the answer you eventually give them. A clear answer with a date on it is still a far kinder thing than the most stressful state a person can be in, which is the one you've been leaving them in by accident.

Feedback

​Subscribe to participate in polls.

If you have specific feedback or anything interesting you’d like to share, please let us know by replying to this email.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Learn Leadership

We are Learn Leadership. We turn real leaders’ stories into practical lessons you can use at work. New editions every Sunday and Thursday.