24 DAYS AGO • 4 MIN READ

The Resignation You Heard About from Someone Else

profile

Learn Leadership

We are Learn Leadership. We turn real leaders’ stories into practical lessons you can use at work. New editions every Sunday and Thursday.

The Resignation You Heard About from Someone Else

Hello Learners,

This is Learn Leadership. Every issue takes one thing that quietly goes wrong between managers and their teams, shows it happening through a real story, and leaves you with something to try this week.

Today it's the resignation you heard about in a corridor, from someone who'd known for days. You'll leave with a twelve-day signal check and one question to ask every person on your team this month.

Monday, 9:10, in the lift

The lift doors were closing when Isabella from HR stepped in, coffee in hand. "Sorry to hear about Amara," she said. "Big loss for your team."

Marcus smiled the way you smile when you've no idea what someone means. He worked it out somewhere between the second and fourth floors. Amara, his best analyst, had resigned. HR had her letter. He didn't.

He had pieced together the rest by lunch. Amara had handed her notice to HR on Friday afternoon, while Marcus was on leave. Two of her teammates had known for twelve days. Her mentor in another department had helped her think through the offer.

Marcus was the last person on the floor to find out, and he'd been in the room for most of the warning.

What was really going on

That afternoon he rebuilt the twelve days from his own calendar and Slack. It took him under an hour.

On day one, Amara turned down leading the next quarter's pricing project. "Someone newer should get the chance," she'd said, and Marcus had thought it was generous.

Four days later her camera stayed off in the team meeting, which it never did. On day six she asked the team admin how unused leave gets paid out. Then she cancelled their one-on-one with "nothing much to discuss this week," and Marcus replied "no worries".

By day ten she was writing handover notes for her two juniors, "in case anyone's off sick." The letter went in on the Friday.

Every signal on its own had an innocent explanation. Together they read like a countdown, and Marcus only saw them together once it had finished.

The pattern underneath

Back in April, Amara had raised her workload twice, once in a one-on-one and once in an email. Marcus said he'd look at it after the quarter closed. The quarter closed, and nobody looked.

So when she stopped raising things, Marcus read the quiet as calm. She'd simply stopped expecting an answer.

Gallup's research says his position is common. Fifty-two percent of people who leave voluntarily say their manager or organization could have done something to keep them. And 51% say that in the three months before they left, no manager or leader talked with them about their job satisfaction or future.

Amara's teammates kept quiet because she asked them to and because nothing in the last six months had told them Marcus wanted to know. That part was his to fix.

What to do Monday

Book a stay conversation with each person on your team, separate from the regular one-on-one. Twenty minutes, built around one question: "What would make you want to stay here another year, and what would make you leave?"

Write the answer down in their words. Do one thing about it within two weeks, and tell them what you did. If you can't do anything, say so and explain why. The follow-through is what makes the next answer honest.

Treat a cancelled one-on-one as information. Keep fifteen minutes anyway: "Happy to skip the agenda, but let's keep a quick catch-up." When someone hands back a stretch project, ask what they'd want to work on before you thank them.

Check your own backlog of promises too. Every "I'll look at it after the quarter" that's still open is a conversation someone has already filed under "won't happen".

Where this goes wrong

A stay conversation can turn into an interrogation. Ask, "Are you looking?" in the first five minutes, and you'll get a polite no from everyone, including the people who are.

Marcus's first instinct was to ask Amara's teammates why nobody told him. That would have taught the whole team to keep the next secret tighter, so he dropped it.

The panic counter-offer is the other trap. A pay rise in someone's notice week answers the letter. It does nothing for the workload she raised in April, and the next person carrying that workload will notice.

And read the letter properly. Citizens Advice tells employees in England who resign because of something their employer did to say so in writing, because the letter can become evidence later. If a reason is in there, treat it as a formal record and take it to HR the same day.

The last way it goes wrong is the slowest. You hold one round of stay conversations, feel good about them, and never run a second. Put the next round in your calendar now, three months out, before the good feeling wears off.

One thing this week

Pick the person on your team you'd least like to lose, and have the stay conversation with them first. You already know who it is.

Marcus called Amara that afternoon and asked for twenty minutes before she left. She still went. The offer was good and she'd decided. She did tell him the real reason, the April workload, and the two analysts carrying the same load had their queues rebalanced the following week.

Six months later, one of them mentioned in a one-on-one that she'd been close to leaving too. What changed her mind was the rebalancing. This time, Marcus heard it from her first.

Feedback

​Subscribe to participate in polls.

If you have specific feedback or anything interesting you’d like to share, please let us know by replying to this email.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Learn Leadership

We are Learn Leadership. We turn real leaders’ stories into practical lessons you can use at work. New editions every Sunday and Thursday.